In a dynamic and rapidly progressing world, the creation of laws and policies is linked to the social, political, economic and cultural norms at play. Understanding the processes, motivations and challenges behind legislative actions is essential for addressing pressing global challenges we face today. It also helps us to grasp the interconnectedness of the societies we live in. In this blog, we will delve into the multifaceted nature of legislative processes, examining the complex interplay between societal needs, political motivations, and legal structures. By understanding the complexities, we can better understand why and how lawmaking is a dynamic process and its role in shaping our world. INTRODUCTION Laws are not static: they are dynamic reflections of societal values, cultural norms and political structures that do not and should not operate in isolation. For example the principle of “presumption of innocence of accused persons” in common law stems from the societal values in human rights, fairness and justice. In the United States, the legacy of racial segregation and discrimination has led to contentious debates on the effectiveness of the legal system in upholding principles of liberty, equality and justice. Laws arise from ideas sparked by public or political concerns in response to a need for change in addressing issues like inequality, climate change, and regressive practices that need to be eradicated. The COVID-19 pandemic, for example, prompted governments worldwide to enact emergency measures that prioritized public health over individual liberties. While necessary in the short term, the measures raised questions about the long-term implications for civil rights and freedoms. Legislative processes Legislative processes differ across different countries due to diverse legal systems and forms of democracy. In most cases, once an idea gains traction, it is introduced as a bill, proposed law, by the legislature( parliament or congress) for consideration. Several stages follow, including readings, reviews and analysis, debates, amendments, and voting. During that process, legislative research is crucial as lawmakers examine existing laws, identify root causes of problems and find gaps to be addressed in order to develop more effective policies. Additionally, lobbying by interest groups, civil societies and other state and non-state actors play a significant role in influencing the legislative outcome by representing the interests and perspectives of various groups. Public participation Public participation is a cornerstone of democracy and good governance in law-making as stated in principle 10 of the Rio Declaration. It drives for transparency and accountability in government policy-making and protects the rights to equality, access to information, and freedom of expression. Public debate, petitions and submissions are effective in creating awareness, providing oversight and resolving conflict; shaping how laws are drafted and implemented. The advancement of technology, particularly through social media and digital activism, has greatly transformed public participation. Citizens have the power to influence policies by voicing their opinions, mobilising around causes and engaging in public debates. They present ideas and opinions on platforms like Instagram, X and Facebook . The 2024 protest in Kenya is an example of how public opinion can influence policy decisions. Citizens created a widespread public outcry against controversies on proposed tax increases using hashtags like #RejectFinanceBill2024 on social media platforms, effectively pressurizing decision-makers to yield to their opinions. Reasons for laws Why do we need these legislation in our nations? Law is crucial for addressing immediate problems in socio-economic, cultural and political dynamics. They maintain order, establish standards of conduct, resolve disputes and protect the rights and liberties of people, corporations and governments. Civil laws protect individual rights to contractual obligations, property ownership, family and child custody matters among others while laws governing relationships between individuals and governments include documents like penal codes that define criminal offences and penalties. Laws also serve as instruments for social change by enabling societies to evolve in response to new challenges such as the marriage equality laws on same-sex marriages and Violence Against Persons (Prohibition) Act in Nigeria on addressing gender based violence. Additionally, laws serve as responses to global challenges as in international agreements like the Paris Agreement for climate change and Kyoto Protocol in addressing environmental protection. These agreements are instruments of cooperation, solidarity, equity, democracy and collaboration among nations in addressing global concerns. They are implemented through national legislations to address these universal challenges. Consequences of legislations Laws shape societies by determining access to services such as education, healthcare, technology and scientific developments, and access to justice. For example laws governing education ensure indiscriminate opportunities to learn regardless of gender, race and socio-economic background. Laws also govern areas like technological advancements in artificial intelligence, intellectual property rights and data privacy. Regulations are necessary in these fields to ensure ethical use of emerging technologies, protection of innovations and protection of individual privacy when handling sensitive information Furthermore, they facilitate reforms in response to evolving values and emerging challenges that not only address immediate concerns ,but also shape the long- term processes ensuring the relevance of legal systems in spite of evolutions. However, the legislative procedures are fraught with complexities. Unintended consequences where new laws have ripple effects that exceed their intended outcomes. For instance a ban on use of plastic bags to minimize land and water pollution may inadvertently lead to increased deforestation due to increased use of paper bags. This fails to wholly eradicate environmental degradation. Secondly, implementation hurdles due to factors such as lack of resources and infrastructure in enforcement of laws whereby; wealthier nations will often have available resources and infrastructure to engage in effective lobbying and advocacy, while developing countries may struggle to implement these practices. This imbalance raises critical questions about the inclusivity of the legislative process on a global scale. Furthermore, political polarization poses a significant challenge to effective lawmaking as citizens focus more on partisanship and ideologies that make it more difficult to pass effective reforms. Change in administration among nations also shifts policy directions as new leadership have different priorities and approaches to governance. This could either result in innovative policies being introduced or regression to previous years. Lastly, controversial matters such as same-sex relations, abortion, and drug and substance use lead to contentious debates. Some legal solutions may be biased towards certain marginalised groups leading to inequitable outcomes that undermine the principles of justice and equality. Conclusion sion The success of modern legislation largely depends on our ability to adapt to new challenges and respond to the needs and aspirations of the people it serves. We must approach lawmaking with a holistic perspective; carefully crafting laws, ensuring their effective implementation and continuously evaluating their societal impacts. Laws shape our rights, freedoms and responsibilities as citizens of our countries and under international policies. Therefore, we must stay informed and actively participate in legislative processes through advocacy, voting, and supporting causes that can influence policies that reflect our aspirations for a just, equitable and sustainable future.
REFERENCES
1. Bygrave, L. A. (2010). Privacy and data protection in an international perspective. Scandinavian studies in law, 56(8), 165-200.
2. Fankhauser, S., Gennaioli, C., & Collins, M. (2014). Domestic dynamics and international influence: What explains the passage of climate change legislation?. Centre for Climate Change Economics and Policy Working Paper, (156). Feldstein, S. (2024). Evaluating Europe's push to enact AI regulations: how will this influence global norms?. Democratization, 31(5), 1049-1066.
3. Kang’ethe, B. M., & Onyango, W. O. Influence of Memes Culture in Shaping Gen Z's Political Engagement: A Case Study of the Reject finance bill 2024 protests.
4. Oxford Analytica. (2024). Kenya’s president and protesters face reform challenge. Emerald Expert Briefings, (oxan-db).
5. Tyler, T. R., & Darley, J. M. (1999). Building a law-abiding society: Taking public views about morality and the legitimacy of legal authorities into account when formulating substantive law. Hofstra L. Rev., 28, 707.
6. Whitsel, L. P., Honeycutt, S., Radcliffe, R., Johnson, J., Chase, P. J., & Noyes, P. (2024). Policy implementation and outcome evaluation: establishing a framework and expanding capacity for advocacy organizations to assess the impact of their work in public policy. Health research policy and systems, 22(1), 27..
Comments